SCTSPRINT3

Issue 100         Thursday 20th February 2020

 

 

C O N T E N T S

 

 

 

 

 

 

Fixing Notice

 

Notice

 

Unopposed Motions

 

Further Procedure Warning List

 

Further Procedure Warning List Personal Injury

 

Open Record Warning List

 

Calling List

 

Inner House Motions

 

Starred and Unstarred Motions

 

Outer House Rolls

 

Inner House Rolls

 

 


FIXING N O T I C E

 

 

The Court of Session current fixing dates are:

 

Civil Jury Trials – 2 June 2020

Personal Injury 4 day Proofs – 22 September 2020

Personal Injury Proofs requiring more than 4 days – 19 December 2020

Ordinary Proofs requiring more than 4 days – 26 May 2020

 

 

 

N O T I C E

 

Act of Sederunt (Rules of the Court of Session 1994, Sheriff Appeal Court Rules and Sheriff Court Rules Amendment) (Reporting Restrictions) 2020

 

This Act of Sederunt amends the Rules of the Court of Session 1994, the Act of Sederunt (Sheriff Appeal Court Rules) 2015, the Ordinary Cause Rules 1993 and the Act of Sederunt (Summary Applications, Statutory Applications and Appeals etc. Rules) 1999.

 

The amendments have the effect of requiring that where the judge or court, as the case may be, is considering making a reporting restriction order then an interim order must always be made first.

 

This Act of Sederunt came into force on 2 March 2020.

 

 

 

N O T I C E

 

Act of Sederunt (Rules of the Court of Session 1994, Sheriff Appeal Court Rules and Sheriff Court Rules Amendment) (Reporting Restrictions) 2020

 

This Act of Sederunt amends the Rules of the Court of Session 1994, the Act of Sederunt (Sheriff Appeal Court Rules) 2015, the Ordinary Cause Rules 1993 and the Act of Sederunt (Summary Applications, Statutory Applications and Appeals etc. Rules) 1999.

 

The amendments have the effect of requiring that where the judge or court, as the case may be, is considering making a reporting restriction order then an interim order must always be made first.

 

This Act of Sederunt came into force on 2 March 2020.

 

 

 

N O T I C E

 

Act of Adjournal (Criminal Procedure Rules 1996 Amendment)

(Miscellaneous) 2020

 

This Act of Adjournal makes a number of amendments to the Criminal Procedure Rules 1996. 

 

Chapter 22 is amended so that applications for review of arrangements for vulnerable witnesses may be determined with, or without, a hearing. Form 22.4 is amended to reflect that change. In addition, rule 22.10 is omitted with the result that it will no longer be necessary for a witness who is to give evidence in chief in the form of a prior statement to be called before the evidence is given.

 

The amendments to Chapter 56 have the effect of requiring that where the judge or court, as the case may be, is considering making a reporting restriction order then an interim order must always be made first.

 

Forms 40.2 and 40.3 are substituted so that the minuter is required to provide detailed information in a structured format when seeking to raise a compatibility issue or a devolution issue.

 

This Act of Sederunt comes into force on 2 March 2020. 

 

 

N O T I C E

 

SCTS Supreme Courts Twitter Account

@sctssupremecrts

 

The Supreme Courts joined twitter in October 2019 and every Thursday the Keeper’s Office will publish the following on a weekly basis –

 

Court of Session’s current fixing dates for Civil Jury Trials, Personal Injury 4 day proofs, Personal Injury proofs requiring more than 4 days and Ordinary action proofs requiring more than 4 days ;

 

Judicial Review petitions for permission awaiting allocation and;

 

Weekly court rolls are published on our website – www.scotcourts.gov.uk

 

Please ‘Follow us on twitter’ button -   twitter_scts

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_______________


UNOPPOSED MOTIONS

 

The following motions were granted, unopposed, on Wednesday 19th February 2020.

 

A640/08 Anna Dyer v Greater Glasgow Health Board

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

A132/17 Cameron Wilson v Grampian Health Board

 

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

 

PD459/16 Gary Maher v Kesgin

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

PD507/19 Graham Richmond v Board of Management of Ayrshire College

 

Clyde & Co

 

A178/18 Allison Dougan &c v Scottish Water

 

Keoghs Scotland LLP

 

A172/19 Myra Boyle v Lanarkshire Health Board

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

A287/16 Anne Hardie &c v Thompsons Solicitors &c

 

Morton Fraser LLP

 

A129/19 Sarah Harris v Tayside Health Board

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

A239/16 Marguerite Keenan v Greater Glasgow Health Board

 

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

 

A342/18 Alexander McConnell v Caledonia Medical Practice

 

Harper Macleod LLP

 

PD373/18 Catherine Sangster &c v Tayside Health Board

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

A76/15 Sarah Duncan v Grampian Health Board

 

Balfour + Manson LLP

 

A389/19 Karen Houston v Toni Milne &c

 

Thorntons Law LLP

 

A147/19 Manjit Ram v James Stirling

 

TLT LLP

 

A43/19 Manjit Ram v James Stirling

TLT LLP

 

 

PD482/19 Jamie Adam v P&H Plant Hire Ltd

 

Thompsons

 

PD423/19 Colin Salmon v Fife Scottish Omnibuses Ltd

Thompsons

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_______________


FURTHER PROCEDURE WARNING LIST

 

 

Further procedure is required in the undernoted case.  Accordingly the case will be put out By Order in the near future.

 

1

A148/17 Amanda Keddie &c v Greater Glasgow & Clyde Health

Digby Brown LLP

MDDUS

 

 

 

 

FURTHER PROCEDURE WARNING LIST

 

PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS

 

 

Further procedure is required in the undernoted case.  Accordingly the case will be put out By Order in the near future.

 

1

PD200/19 Alexander Moodie v Scottish Power UK Plc

 

Digby Brown LLP

Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP

 

 

 

 

OPEN RECORD WARNING LIST

 

 

Open Records have not been lodged timeously in the undernoted case.  Accordingly the cause will be put out By Order in the near future.

 

1

A347/18 Legal & General Assurance v Halliday Fraser Munro &c

Eversheds LLP

Davidson Chalmers Stewart LLP

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

 

 

 

Brandon Malone & Co

 

 

 

 

_______________


COURT OF SESSION

 

 

CALLING LIST

 

Thursday 20th February

 

1

PD23/20 William Macphee AG (First) Antony Zanre &c

Digby Brown LLP

 

2

PD21/20 (First) Corrina Knape &c AG The Advocate General for Scotland

Digby Brown LLP

 

3

PD25/20 Roy Kinghorn AG Scottish Special Housing Association

Digby Brown LLP

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_______________


Friday 21st February

 

EXTRA DIVISION

 

INNER HOUSE UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

CA131/16 Argo Invest Overseas Ltd v Morgan Associates

 

BTO

 

 

CA85/16 Argo Invest Overseas Ltd v Stewart Milne Group &c

BTO

 

 

 

 

 

LORD PENTLAND

 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

P23/20 Pet: Andrew Brown for Judicial Review

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

P62/20 Pet: Lee Macintosh for Judicial Review

 

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

P664/19 Pet: Nuveen Real Estate Ltd for Judicial Review

 

Morton Fraser LLP

 

 

P144/20 PPP for Judicial Review

 

Clan Childlaw

 

 

 

P1055/19 Pet: William Beggs

Drummond Miller LLP

 

 

 

 

 

LORD BOYD OF DUNCANSBY

 

UNSTARRED MOTIONS

 

A245/18 Michael Blower &c v Colin Tock &c

 

Thorley Stephenson

 

 

A201/18 Kevin Dunn v Greater Glasgow Health Board

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

 

 
LORD DOHERTY

 

UNSTARRED MOTION

 

P142/20 Pet: Vaughan engineering Ltd to extend admin

Morton Fraser LLP

 

 

 

 

 

LADY WISE

 

UNSTARRED MOTION

 

PD23/20 William MacPhee &c v Antony Zanre &c

Flexlaw Ltd

 

 

 

 

 

LORD CLARK

 

STARRED MOTIONS

 

30mins

A234/19 Lee Montague-Trenchard v Cannons Law Practice

Thompsons

BTO

 

 

A232/19 Jonathan Gough v Cannons Law Practice

Thompsons

BTO

 

 

 

 


TO BE ALLOCATED

 

STARRED MOTIONS

 

1½hrs

A720/14 David Taylor &c v Lothian Health Board

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

Blackadders LLP

 

30mins

A321/18 George Lafferty v George Amil &c

Drummond Miller LLP

Gibson Kerr Law & Property

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_______________


OUTER HOUSE ROLLS

 

 

LORD GLENNIE – TBC, Clerk

 

Wednesday 26th February

 

Oral Hearing

At 9.30am

 

P872/19 Pet: Mirwais Ahmadzai for Judicial Review

Drummond Miller LLP

Office of the Advocate General

 

 

 

 

LORD BRAILSFORD – R Newlands, Clerk

 

Wednesday 26th February

 

By Order

At 9.30am

 

F29/19 Danielle Williamson v Campbell Williamson

Thorley Stephenson

SKO Family Ltd

 

 

Procedural Hearing

 

A14/18 Margaret Prichard &c v Eui Ltd Trading

Allan McDougall

BLM

 

 

By Order

 

P1224/18 Pet: Andrew Lennon for Judicial Review

Balfour + Manson LLP

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

Thursday 27th February

 

FAMILY ACTION

In terms of Rule 49, a proof has been allowed in the following action

 

F64/19 Gina Al Yozobakee v Crispin Boys Ponder

Brodies LLP

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

 

 

Friday 28th February

 

By Order

In terms of Rule of Court 43.6(3)

 

PD360/19 Kirsty MacLeod v South Ayrshire Council

 

Digby Brown LLP

Clyde & Co

 

PD451/19 Robert Dixon v Veolia energy & Utility Services UK Plc

Digby Brown LLP

Clyde & Co

 

 

 LORD TYRE – T. Sadler, Clerk

Monday 24th February

By Order
at 9am


PD836/14 AB v Transform Medical Group (CS) Ltd
Thompsons Clyde & Co
PD2787/14 CD v Transform Medical Group (CS) Ltd
Thompsons Clyde & Co

 

LORD DOHERTY – C Munn, Clerk

 

Tuesday 25th February

 

By Order

Between 9.00am and 9.30am

 

CA104/18 A&E Investments &c v Levy & McRae Solicitors LLP &c

Davidson Chalmers Stewart LLP

DWF LLP

Brodies LLP

 

Preliminary Hearing

Between 9.30am and 10.00am

 

CA178/19 Briggs of Burton Plc v Doosan Babcock Ltd

Eversheds LLP

Dentons UK

 

 

Wednesday 26th February

 

Starred Motion

At 9.00am

 

CA86/19 David Grier v Chief Inspector Police Service of Scotland

Kennedys Scotland

Ledingham Chalmers LLP

A & WM Urquhart

 

Thursday 27th February

 

Continued Preliminary Hearing

At 9.00am

 

CA6/19 The Royal Bank of Scotland Plc v Alison Donnelly &c

Pinsent Masons LLP

Blacklocks

 

 

 

 

LADY WISE – T Kell, Clerk

 

Tuesday 25th February

 

Proof (8 days)

 

F28/19 Lisa Tobias v Graeme Tobias

 

Morton Fraser LLP

 

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

 

 

Wednesday 26th February

 

Continued By Order

At 9.15am

 

AD26/19 Pet: Edinburgh City Council for permanence order re ADMS

The City of Edinburgh Council

 

 

 

AD27/19 Pet: Edinburgh City Council for permanence order re SDS

The City of Edinburgh Council

 

 

 

Procedural Hearing

 

A36/19 Gavin McDonald v Lothian Health Board

 

Digby Brown LLP

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

 

 

LADY WOLFFE – C Stark, Clerk

 

Monday 24th February

 

Hearing on the Minutes and Answers

 

A179/19 Transocean Drilling UK Ltd v Greenpeace Ltd &cv

Pinsent Masons LLP

Harper Macleod LLP

 

 

Wednesday 26th February

 

Pre-Proof By Order

At 9.00am

 

CA132/18 Memorial Walls Ltd v The Rangers Football Club Ltd

MacRoberts LLP

Anderson Strathern LLP

 

 

Thursday 27th February

 

Procedural Hearing

At 9.00am

 

CA126/18 Clydebank Housing Association v CCG (Scotland) Ltd

Lindsays

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

 

 

 

 


LORD CLARK – J Hannah, Clerk

 

Tuesday 25th February

 

Proof (4 days)

 

CA109/17 Ian Rennie v Mark Rennie &c

Addleshaw Goddard

Ennova Law

 

 

Friday 28th February

 

Preliminary Hearing

Between 9.30am and 10.00am

 

CA163/19 Robert Kidd v Lime Rock Management LLP &c

Harper Macleod LLP

Gilson Gray LLP

 

 

 

 

LORD ERICHT – L Cranston, Clerk

 

Tuesday 25th February

 

Proof Before Answer (4 days)

 

CA1/18 MG construction Ltd v AGD Equipment Ltd

Brandon Malone & Co

Anderson Strathern LLP

 

 

Wednesday 26th February

 

By Order

At 9.30am

 

CA75/19 Drum Income Plus Ltd v LS Buchanan Ltd

Brodies LLP

CMS

 

 

 

 


LADY CARMICHAEL – TBC, Clerk

 

Tuesday 25th February

 

Continued Proof Before Answer

 

A138/18 Douglas Soulsby v Richard Jones &c

Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP

DLA Piper Scotland LLP

 

 

 

 

LORD SUMMERS – L Morgan, Clerk

 

Wednesday 26th February

 

By Order (Adjustment) Roll

 

A55/18 Anne Labus &c v Forth Valley Health Board

Harper Macleod LLP

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

By Order

 

A141/18 Stephanie Robertson v Dumfries & Galloway Health Board

Drummond Miller LLP

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

Thursday 27th February

 

By Order

 

PD2830/09 Thomas Gardner v Scottish Power UK Plc

 

Thompsons

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

Shepherd & Wedderburn LLP

 

PD142/19 Edward Kearney v McLaren Building Group Ltd

Thompsons

Clyde & Co

 

 

Friday 28th February

 

Procedural Hearing

 

A119/18 Bryan Nimmo v Ayrshire & Arran Health Board

Anderson Strathern LLP

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

By Order

 

PD1644/14 Patrick Docherty v Cape Insulation Ltd &c

Thompsons

Clyde & Co

Brodies LLP

 

 

 

LORD ARTHURSON – C Munn, Clerk

 

Wednesday 26th February

 

Procedural Hearing

 

A269/17 Steven Kilpatrick v South Beach Medical Centre &c

Thompsons

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

MDDUS

 

By Order (Adjustment) Roll

 

A249/18 Graeme Roger &c v Grampian Health Board

 

Bonnar Accident Law

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

A237/19 John Reid &c v NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde

Slater & Gordon Lawyers

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

Thursday 27th February

 

By Order

 

A321/18 George Lafferty v George Amil &c

Drummond Miller LLP

Jones Whyte Law

Party

 

Friday 28th February

 

By Order

In terms of Rule 43.6(3)

 

PD441/19 David McNeill &c v MacTaggart & Mickel Homes Ltd

Thompsons

DAC Beachcroft Scotland LLP

 

 

By Order

In terms of Rule 43.10(3)

 

PD5/18 David Scullion v Patricia McGurk &c

Gildeas

Weightmans (Scotland) LLP

 

 

 

 

TO BE ALLOCATED

 

Tuesday 25th February 2020

 

Proof (6 days)

 

A421/16 Katarzyna Borkowska &c v Greater Glasgow Health Board

 

Harper Macleod LLP

 

Shoosmiths LLP

 

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

 


Tuesday 25th February 2020

 

PERSONAL INJURY ACTIONS

 

Proof (4 days)

 

PD271/19 Isabel McInroy v Avant Homes (Scotland) Ltd

 

Digby Brown LLP

 

Clyde & Co

 

PD170/19 Stewart Henderson &c v Kendrick Computing Plc &c

Thompsons

Clyde & Co

 

 

 

 

TO BE ALLOCATED

 

Wednesday 26th February 2020

 

Procedural Hearing

 

P741/19 Pet: Ion Rusu for Judicial Review

 

Drummond Miller LLP

Office of the Advocate General

 

 

 

 

TO BE ALLOCATED

 

Thursday 27th February 2020

 

Procedure Roll

 

A425/16 Cheryl Binnie v Victor Lopes &c

 

TLT LLP

NHS Scotland Central Legal Office

 

 

 

 


TO BE ALLOCATED

 

Friday 28th February 2020

 

Substantive Hearing

 

P807/19 Pet: Grant White for Judicial Review

 

Party

DWF LLP

 

P808/19 Pet: Grant White for Judicial Review

 

Party

DWF LLP

 

Procedural Hearing

 

P929/19 Pet: William Rooney for Judicial Review

Drummond Miller LLP

SGLD

 

 

 

 

INNER HOUSE ROLLS

 

 

FIRST DIVISION

 

Wednesday 26th February

 

Continued Procedural Hearings

At 9.45am

 

(P1136/17 Reclaiming Motion – Lady

(Carmichael - Joseph Millbank v The

(Scottish Ministers &c

(

Drummond Miller LLP

SGLD

 

(P514/18 Reclaiming Motion – Lady

(Carmichael - AP v The

(Scottish Ministers &c

(

Drummond Miller LLP

SGLD

 

(P511/18 Reclaiming Motion – Lady

(Carmichael – Gordon Burns v The

(Scottish Ministers &c

Drummond Miller LLP

SGLD

 

 

Summar Roll

 

P209/17 Reclaiming Motion – Lord Brailsford – Jordan Queen v The Lord Advocate as representing the Scottish Ministers &c

TC Young LLP

SGLD

 

 

Friday 28th February

 

Summar Roll

 

A473/13 Reclaiming Motion – Lord Doherty – Sajjad Soofi v Jeffery Dykes, t/a Dykes Glass & Co

Party

CMS

 

 

 

 

EXTRA DIVISION

 

Tuesday 25th February

 

Procedural Hearing

 

XA113/19 Crofters Common Grazings v The Crofting Commission &c

Gillespie Macandrew

Crofting Commission

Pinsent Masons LLP

 

Thursday 27th February

 

Procedural Hearing

 

P600/19 Reclaiming Motion – Lady Wolffe – Pet: Damilola Omotayo for Judicial Review

Drummond Miller LLP

Office of the Advocate General

 

 

Single Bill

Between 10.00am and 11.30am

 

XA58/19 Application for leave to appeal – Bahman Mawlani v The Secretary of State for the Home Department

Drummond Miller LLP

Office of the Advocate General

 

_______________